Showing posts with label Native Americans. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Native Americans. Show all posts

Thursday, January 13, 2022

Just Wondering - Tracking Authenticity

This month's column by Manitowoc (WI) Public Library Youth Librarian Susie Menk explores questions about how far we go in our research during book selection to determine authenticity in content. And she's wondering....what do you think? 

Pixabay image

Recently, I received a box of books to preview from a new book vendor.  I have always appreciated being able to actually look at the books when making decisions about ordering.  It’s so much more satisfying that just reading reviews and hoping you are picking something that your patrons will love.  


This particular box happened to have several books on Native Americans.  Having taken several classes and workshops about diversity and inclusion, I was more thorough about looking these books over and evaluating whether their representation is authentic or not.  As I looked through the book I was struck by the credit statements in the front pages that the images used came from stock photos on the internet. As I continued to look through the end pages, there were very few resources listed in the bibliography as well.  Immediately my antennae went up!  I decided to do some digging into the author.  As I searched the American Indians in Children’s Literature (AICL) site, I couldn’t find the author listed or the titles of the books.  I also checked the CCBC Diversity Book Finder and there was nothing there. More red flags went up!


Then I looked for more information on the author..  The author had no visible ties or any information listing that they identified as a Native American.  While I know that authors can write on a variety of topics, there were just too many red flags for me to ignore–lack of resources, stock photos, and an author not identifying as Native American.  These red flags led me to question the authenticity of the material and eventually I decided not to purchase the book.


So my question for you is—how much time do you spend looking carefully at the books you order to determine if the book is authentic?  In this particular case, I could do a more in-depth search since I had the book in front of me.  What happens when you are just reading a review?  Most reviews are short paragraphs.  How does a reviewer cover everything they need to share about a book in such a short amount of words?  How do you balance taking time to verify a book’s authenticity and getting other projects or work done in a timely manner?  Do you rely heavily on the written reviews or do you have specific reviewers that you use whose judgment you trust?

Monday, March 11, 2019

New Resource Manual - American Indian Studies in WI

Robin Amado, part of the FB group Wisconsin Librarians and Teachers Supporting Act 31, recently shared an advanced printing of amazing resource for all of Wisconsin staff working with children: American Indian Studies in Wisconsin (Act 31) Resource Manual compiled and written by Caryl Pfaff, librarian at the Lac Courte Oreilles Ojibwa Community College Library in Hayward WI.


The need to educate WI residents by sharing accurate information about tribal histories and culture led in 1989/91 "to the creation of Wisconsin Act 31 that requires all students and teachers within the state of Wisconsin receive instruction on the history, culture, and tribal sovereignty of the American Indian nations and tribal communities in Wisconsin. This instruction is required for students at least twice in the elementary and once in the high school grades. This resource manual has been developed to help teachers, students, librarians, and parents identify quality materials that will help support Act 31 endeavors."

This resource guide, funded by an IMLS grant, shares information, curriculum and booklists for elementary and secondary age youth on both WI tribes and those outside of WI. There are acquisition sources for materials listed in the 66 page manual as well as a wide array of information of use to libraries of all types throughout WI. This resource is a treasure trove for collection development for all ages in libraries!

Thursday, December 6, 2018

Tuesday, November 20, 2018

November is Native American Heritage Month

As librarians, we know how important it is that kids see themselves in books--and see others in books, as well.  #weneeddiversebooks, aimirite?! 

When is the last time you assessed your collection for books/titles containing Indigenous characters?

“Most of what kids see in books today are best sellers & classics that stereotype & misrepresent Native people in history. There’s a lot of bias in them. The books that I recommend are ones that can counter that bias in several ways. One, they’re not stereotypical. Two, most of them are set in the present day, which is important in countering what we see in a lot of children’s & young adult literature, which says that we vanished, we didn’t make it to the present day, and of course we did.” 
     - Debbie Reese, Nambe Pueblo, of American Indians in Children’s Literature

At this year's WLA, Valerie Morris of Whitefish Bay Public Library presented on just such a topic during her session, Experiences in Weeding Insensitive Picture Books About Native Americans.  The PowerPoint about the presentation is now available on the WLA website--and through THIS LINK.

Perhaps you're looking for more books written and/or illustrated by Indigenous people to help enhance your collection?  Try the blog American Indians in Children's Literature!  Or take a gander at this delightful booklist containing titles for children written by Indigenous authors.

  


For an idea how best to select and utilize these titles in your programming/classrooms/what-have-you, be sure to check out the following article from the July 2018 edition of Language Arts written by Debbie Reese: Critical Indigenous Literacies: Selecting and Using Children’s Books about Indigenous Peoples.  

Here are a few other online resources to explore:

National Congress of American Indians
Wisconsin First Nations: American Indian Studies in Wisconsin

 Image result for hiawatha the peacemaker

Friday, August 17, 2018

2019 National May Hill Arbuthnot Lecture Scheduled in Madison!!

Debbie Reese, PhD
An alert peer noticed a tweet on August 11 from the CCBC's KT Horning:

"Mark Your Calendars! The 2019 May Hill Arbuthnot Lecture by @debreese wil take place in Madison WI on Saturday April 13 7:30 pm. #2019Arbuthnot, @UWMadison@wearealsc"

This is big news! The CCBC, UW School of Education and UW-Madison iSchool successfully collaborated on an application to host this annual honored lecture featuring Dr. Debbie Reese, champion of of Native representation and strong advocate for inclusion.

The free Arbuthnot lecture is held all over the US (last year in Bellingham WA) so having it close to home is great!

You can read about the details of next year's lecture here and read general information about the lecture and Arbuthnot here.

Mark those calendars now for Saturday April 13 at 7:30 pm. We'll keep you posted on location, how to get free tickets and final details as they happen!


Tuesday, October 31, 2017

Thinking About Your Library's Thanksgiving Collection

With the spotlight on diversity and inclusion, November is a good time to take a look at your library's Thanksgiving collection. It may be time to select new materials that reflect Native American perspectives on Thanksgiving, evaluate and deselect materials that are outdated, biased, inaccurate or misrepresentative. As you create displays or hang posters, consider what you are showing and who might be seeing it.

Resources you might want to use:

Debbie Reese's 2009 article on American Indian Perspectives on Thanksgiving 

Debbie Reese's 2014 article about Oyate's List of Books to Avoid, as well as books Debbie recommends

The educator's page at the National Museum of the American Indian (NAMI) website

American Indian Library Association book reviews page

Oyate's website where you can find book reviews, resources, workshops, and criteria for evaluating books for anti-Indian bias

The paper "I is for Inclusion: The Portrayal of Native Americans in Books for Young People" which covers background, evaluation, and sources for books among other things.

The Resource List from the WLA Preconference Representation, Authenticity, and Being Real: Diversity in Youth Services presented by Anna Haase Krueger and Tamara Lee of the Ramsey County Library, MN 

This list is by no means exhaustive, so please share your resources or suggestions in the comments.  

Wednesday, November 2, 2016

Go Team that Needs to Change It's Name and Logo!

My hometown baseball team is in the World Series.  There are two things I hope happen: Cubs fans have to wait another year for a title and Cleveland changes it's name and Chief Wahoo logo.  Watching the games, I am hear myself saying why do people think this is okay, why is that fan dressed in Native headdress, why can't we change it.  The Cleveland Indians have been moving away from the logo but the race to the World Series has brought it back and also the opposition to it.

Growing up, I was surrounded by streets named after long gone tribes.  When I moved to Wisconsin for college, there were active tribes.  Native people were no longer in the past tense or an abstract concept.  They were and still are real people.

One reason I was drawn to librarianship was because you encourage people to be curious about the world and seek out information to learn about stuff, places, people like you but also different from you. In the last few years, I have been actively seeking out resources on diversity to better understand my privilege and to better serve and understand all types of children and their families.

Resources I seek out and probably discovered through the YSS blog. Please add ones in the comments.

Tuesday, July 19, 2016

Collection Development Webinar Today

From Tessa Michaelson Schmidt, Public Library Youth and Inclusive Services Consultant, Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction

Dear Library Staff Serving Youth,

Please considering registering for this FREE webinar today hosted by the Association of Library Service to Children. All public collections for youth in our state could benefit from a refreshed consideration of Native American authenticity. Spots in this webinar are limited; however, anyone who registers will get a link to the archived session.

Description: Are you worried that your collection of books by/about Native peoples is in need of a 21st century update so that it accurately reflects Native peoples of the past and present? Are you concerned that your collection has too many biased depictions of them? In this webinar, Dr. Debbie Reese will offer tips and ideas to think about as you select and weed your collections.

For more information, visit:

Wednesday, May 18, 2016

Thunder Boy Jr.


Deb Reese, who blogs at American Indians in Children's Literature, writes informational and thoughtful posts about - you guessed it - American Indians in children's literature. If you haven't read her blog, take a look! It's a great resource. Her latest series of posts surrounds Sherman Alexie's new book Thunder Boy Jr. and has prompted some interesting discussion in the greater library world. See her first post here, and check out the links to her other posts at the bottom of the page.

Friday, November 20, 2015

How To Be a Good Ally For Indigenous Writers

If you are struggling to serve an indigenous population, or just want to accurately represent indigenous peoples in your collection, take a minute to read this excellent article from Wordcraft Circle, an organization that promotes the work of Native American writers and storytellers.

How to Be a Good Ally for Indigenous Writers

Looking for further inspiration?  Wordcraft Circle Honors and Awards are great resources for finding authors, works, and other materials that demonstrate excellence in indigenous literature.

The 2015 list can be accessed here: Honors and Awards