Thursday, February 11, 2021

Just Wondering - Collection Development Tools

This post by Manitowoc (WI) Public Library Youth Librarian and YSS Board Member Susie Menk explores what tools - both software and innate savviness - one can use when doing weeding and doing collection development. And she's wondering....what do you think? 

Image by Sabine Schulte from Pixabay

Collection development is a necessary part of library work.  If we keep ordering new books, we have to have somewhere to put them.  We can’t keep all the books or we would eventually run out of space and have to add on to our buildings or build new buildings.  We need to maintain a balance between the new items we order and the items we must discard. 

Most libraries have a set of tools to help us do this work of collection development.  We have collection development policies set down by our director, managers and library boards.  We have a knowledge of our patrons and what their likes and dislikes are.  We have the training that teaches us how to evaluate books based on their age, usage, relevant information and condition.  Many of us have expectations set up by our supervisors or regular weeding and collection purchasing tasks.  We read magazines that give us reviews on books.  We read books, books, and more books to keep up with what’s popular. We talk to our friends, co-workers, other librarians and patrons to find out what titles are new and exciting and which ones don’t appeal.  This is our box of tools. 

Today let’s talk about another tool—collection development software.  My library is currently looking at getting rid of the software program we use and going back to using software that is connected to our ILS (Integrated Library System).  Different companies sell collection development software.  My library has been using one called collectionHQ©, owned by Baker & Taylor.  (B&T, as it is affectionately known, is one of the biggest book distributors to libraries.)

collectionHQ© software allows libraries to run reports on the items in their collection.  You can run weeding lists, grubby lists, dead lists and collection checklists (which is basically a shelf list).  Reports can be specific to collections or departments and are separated by fiction, non-fiction and non-book items (like music cds and flannelgraphs).  The software can even tell you what collections are overstocked and understocked.  Sounds like a great collection development tool, right?

As we found out at our library, collectionHQ© can be a great tool as long you don’t totally rely on it.  It’s a starting place and the lists we ran helped us with our collection development, but there are flaws to the system.  For more on that see this article https://www.infotoday.com/cilmag/sep20/index.shtml .  Don’t get me wrong, software can be a great tool, but remember it isn’t your only tool.  Your knowledge of your collection and community is just as important.

So now we are making plans to go back to running reports through our ILS.  These reports can be tailored a bit more to help us find more specific items for weeding.  For instance, I plan to run a list for items with older publication dates.  Our ILS report system can look for publication dates as well as dates we catalogued an item.  That can be helpful if we replaced an older publication with a more recent copy. 

Tools for collection development can be useful.  I use them all the time, but they are not without their flaws.  No one tool can do everything.  It’s a constant learning process.  As I learn more about publishers, software, authors, racial equality, and diversity I realize that I must keep learning in order to do a good job with collection development.  The more I know about the world of books-tools, publishers, authors, etc. -- the better my knowledge base will be to do what is best for my community. 

What about you?  What is your favorite or most frustrating part  of collection development?  Have some favorite tools?  Do you dread doing weeding or buying?  Do you use software tools or ILS reports?  I’d love to hear what works for you!

 P.S. For additional tools don’t forget to check out these ideas on the ALA website!


No comments: